Thomas Pausz - Vegetal Media: Difference between revisions
Thomas Pausz (talk | contribs) I created a page for the Interstices 1000 word text with deadline on the 16th of November. |
Thomas Pausz (talk | contribs) m I uploaded my 1000 word draft. |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<div class="metadata"> | <div class="metadata"> | ||
== | == Overflowing Life == | ||
'''Thomas Pausz''' | '''Thomas Pausz''' | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
=== | === Greenhouses as Leaking Artificial Ecosystems === | ||
== Introduction: the greenhouse as a zone-to-think == | |||
Where are the gaps in the technological enclosure of the capitalist greenhouse? This contribution to ''Interstices'' approaches the greenhouse as a structure, whose technologies of enclosure and artificial care produce the very gaps they cannot fill: cracks in climate control, unruly growth, noise the sensors cannot capture. From the Wardian case to Precision Horticulture's automated landscapes,<ref name="automated">Bedir, Merve, Lieke Groen, Marten Kuijpers, Víctor Muñoz Sanz, and Marina Otero Verzier, eds. ''Automated Landscapes''. Rotterdam: Het Nieuwe Instituut, 2023.</ref> successive and increasingly complex infrastructures of glass, steel and algorithmic governance have attempted to close these openings, converting what Parikka and Gil-Fournier call ''medianatures'' into docile, legible, extractable data.<ref>Parikka, Jussi, and Abelardo Gil-Fournier. ''Living Surfaces: Images, Plants, and Environments of Media''. MIT Press, 2024.</ref> Yet, following the critical work of the Digital Ecologies research group, such closures are never total.<ref>Turnbull, Jonathon, Adam Searle, Oscar Hartman Davies, Jessica Dodsworth, et al., eds. ''Digital Ecologies: Mediating More-than-Human Worlds''. Manchester University Press, 2024.</ref> But what if instead of tracing the progress of these technologies of life enclosures, and their ever-more cognitive and agentic infrastructures, we attempted an archeology of their failures? | |||
= | To think from these gaps, I first refer to Ségolène Guinard's fieldwork on the artificial ecosystems of space capsules as privileged sites to "think" about entangled ecologies. Through a micro-phenomenology of the interactions between humans, machinic systems and biological systems aboard the International Space Station, Guinard studies the strange relations between humans and the plants they grow and care for in outer space. In ''Capsular Existence'', she argues that the space capsule "must remain a zone-to-think (that we must think about and from which we can think)".<ref name="guinard">Guinard, Ségolène. "Capsular Existence." ''Multitudes'' 85 (2021): 139–148. https://doi.org/10.3917/mult.085.0139</ref> With Guinard, we can argue that the "humble ecology" of the space capsule extends to describe our shared reality today, and the climate-controlled spaces we increasingly dwell in with our companion species, biological or synthetic. Peter Sloterdijk already made London's Crystal Palace the emblem of a "world interior of capital": a giant glasshouse where comfort and artificial atmospheres are maintained for those inside, while harsh realities are kept outside the glass walls.<ref>Sloterdijk, Peter. ''In the World Interior of Capital: For a Philosophical Theory of Globalization''. Translated by Wieland Hoban. Polity, 2013.</ref> Studio D.O.T.S.'s ''Greenhouse Stories'' shows how such interiors now extend into entire landscapes of production.<ref>Studio D.O.T.S. ''Greenhouse Stories''. Studio D.O.T.S., 2024.</ref> | ||
The concept from Guinard that I wish to expand on and diffract is that of '''overflowing life''': life that cannot be completely contained or repressed by technological control. Guinard locates a resistance to capsular existence in the "slippage from laboratory to overflowing life", in plants that refuse to thrive and thereby defer the efficiency of the space programmes as a whole. She calls for revealing, "in the interstices of scientific devices", a relationship to care and to everything that cannot be mastered.<ref>Guinard, "Capsular Existence," p. VI (English translation).</ref> Rather than a site of total control, the greenhouse can therefore be approached as a ''leaking'' artificial ecosystem. I propose to follow these leaks across three registers: technical, fictional and theoretical. | |||
== 1. Technical overflows == | |||
In ''Automated Landscapes'', Marina Otero Verzier and the Het Nieuwe Instituut team document contemporary work environments at the forefront of automation, from dairy farms and greenhouses to data centres. The case studies evidence the real ecological consequences of building and powering giant artificial greenhouses and the data infrastructures they need.<ref name="automated" /> As a counterpoint to this seminal critique, in her lecture ''On Heat, Desire, and the Thermopolitics of Data'' at the PARSE conference ''Some Like It Hot'', Otero Verzier analysed several real-life examples where organic life disturbs algorithmic governance systems.<ref>Otero Verzier, Marina. "On Heat, Desire, and the Thermopolitics of Data." Plenary lecture, ''Some Like It Hot'', 6th biennial PARSE conference, Röhsska Museum of Design and Craft, University of Gothenburg, 13 November 2025.</ref> | |||
This first section of my research collects such documented incidents in greenhouses and other "capsules", where infestation, contamination, unexpected growth or the improvised gestures of human carers disrupt the apparatus. Guinard for example records one in the MELiSSA life-support system, where a technician confides, half-guiltily, that contamination is what makes working with the living interesting.<ref>Guinard, "Capsular Existence," p. VIII (English translation).</ref> What registers as error, noise or anomaly in the data streams is here valued as a trace of overflowing life. | |||
== 2. Fictional overflows == | |||
In resonance with ''The Three-Body Problem'' and the dark forest theory of the internet,<ref>Liu, Cixin. ''The Dark Forest''. Translated by Joel Martinsen. Tor Books, 2015 [2008]; Konior, Bogna. ''The Dark Forest Theory of the Internet''. Polity, 2026.</ref> this section scrutinizes the mediation of greenhouse ecosystems and biospheres through film and science fiction, to sketch an aesthetics of overflowing life, leakage and system breakdown, and identify its impact on technological imaginaries. | |||
In his documentary ''Agrilogistics'', Gerard Ortín Castellví takes us behind the closed doors of Precision Horticulture in mega automated industrial greenhouses in the Netherlands, where tulip bulbs, chrysanthemum stems and vine tomatoes are processed through cameras feeding the datasets and algorithms that regulate their growth. For Ortín, "the greenhouse is a cinematic device, an automated film set".<ref>Ortín Castellví, Gerard, dir. ''Agrilogistics''. UK/Spain, 2022. 21 min. Berlinale Shorts 2022.</ref> At the end of the film, after the machinic order has totally taken over the plant life, and the mesmerizing dance of computer vision and farmbots has reshaped our flux of consciousness, this weird ecology is suddenly subverted: the shadow of an animal (a llama or an alpaca?) furtively crosses the frame to go chew on some leaves. This sudden clumsy and woolly life form disrupts the implacable rhythm of the farmbots, and for a micro-second we wonder if a rewilding of these automated landscapes is actually on the way (the truth is far more sinister…). | |||
I will study other key mediations where life overflows the technological apparatus, or where the apparatus is hacked by human or non-human agencies to produce a surplus of life: the documentary ''Spaceship Earth'' on Biosphere 2,<ref>Wolf, Matt, dir. ''Spaceship Earth''. Neon, 2020.</ref> alongside news coverage and research on the project's spectacular failures, including Benjamin Bratton's reading of Biosphere 2, with its ant and cockroach infestations, as an accurate simulation of how utopian closed-loop microsocieties implode;<ref>Bratton, Benjamin H. "For a General Theory of Simulations." Lecture, University of Southern California / Antikythera, Los Angeles, 11 January 2024. https://antikythera.org/general-theory-of-simulations</ref> Douglas Trumbull's cult film ''Silent Running'' (1972), where a botanist sabotages his own mission to save the last forests of Earth, enclosed in geodesic domes adrift in space.<ref>Trumbull, Douglas, dir. ''Silent Running''. Written by Deric Washburn, Michael Cimino, and Steven Bochco. Universal Pictures, 1972.</ref> | |||
== 3. Theoretical overflows == | |||
Where the dark forest names a withdrawal into silence and refusal, I turn to Benjamin Bratton's "rainforest" model of the internet as a counter-figure: dense, entangled, interdependent affective exchanges rather than concealment.<ref>Bratton, Benjamin H. "Alternative Models of AI (at Urban Scale)." Strelka Talks, Strelka Institute for Media, Architecture and Design, Moscow, n.d. Video lecture.</ref> Read against the greenhouse, the rainforest theory of the internet suggests that gaps in dominant infrastructures need not only shelter retreat: they can also host noisy, overflowing, more-than-human forms of exchange and dwelling, faint signals and unidentified affects. | |||
Post-digital ecologies demand a new vocabulary, and a compositionist ethics beyond "artificial" and "natural" divides.<ref>Latour, Bruno. "An Attempt at a 'Compositionist Manifesto'." ''New Literary History'' 41, no. 3 (2010): 471–490.</ref> This theoretical section explores new concepts in ecolinguistics<ref>Stibbe, Arran. ''Ecolinguistics: Language, Ecology and the Stories We Live By''. 2nd ed. Routledge, 2021.</ref> that attempt to describe our relation to artificially created and sustained biological life, and to A-life.<ref>Helmreich, Stefan. ''Silicon Second Nature: Culturing Artificial Life in a Digital World''. University of California Press, 1998.</ref> The language of control names overflows as failures, pests, contaminations or noise. Which new words could describe forms of life that are neither wild nor engineered, but have leaked through both? | |||
== Questions for the workshop == | |||
* Can overflowing life be ''designed for'', or does any design of the gap close it again? | |||
* Is the overflow an aesthetic category (the furtive, the nocturnal, the infested), or does it also have a biopolitics (biopolitics begins as an enclosure, wrote Sloterdijk)? | |||
* How should a dark forest be read from inside the greenhouse: greenhouse as hiding place, dwelling or habitat? | |||
<references /> | |||
[[Category:Interstices]] | [[Category:Interstices]] | ||
Latest revision as of 01:15, 17 November 2026
Greenhouses as Leaking Artificial Ecosystems
Introduction: the greenhouse as a zone-to-think
Where are the gaps in the technological enclosure of the capitalist greenhouse? This contribution to Interstices approaches the greenhouse as a structure, whose technologies of enclosure and artificial care produce the very gaps they cannot fill: cracks in climate control, unruly growth, noise the sensors cannot capture. From the Wardian case to Precision Horticulture's automated landscapes,[1] successive and increasingly complex infrastructures of glass, steel and algorithmic governance have attempted to close these openings, converting what Parikka and Gil-Fournier call medianatures into docile, legible, extractable data.[2] Yet, following the critical work of the Digital Ecologies research group, such closures are never total.[3] But what if instead of tracing the progress of these technologies of life enclosures, and their ever-more cognitive and agentic infrastructures, we attempted an archeology of their failures?
To think from these gaps, I first refer to Ségolène Guinard's fieldwork on the artificial ecosystems of space capsules as privileged sites to "think" about entangled ecologies. Through a micro-phenomenology of the interactions between humans, machinic systems and biological systems aboard the International Space Station, Guinard studies the strange relations between humans and the plants they grow and care for in outer space. In Capsular Existence, she argues that the space capsule "must remain a zone-to-think (that we must think about and from which we can think)".[4] With Guinard, we can argue that the "humble ecology" of the space capsule extends to describe our shared reality today, and the climate-controlled spaces we increasingly dwell in with our companion species, biological or synthetic. Peter Sloterdijk already made London's Crystal Palace the emblem of a "world interior of capital": a giant glasshouse where comfort and artificial atmospheres are maintained for those inside, while harsh realities are kept outside the glass walls.[5] Studio D.O.T.S.'s Greenhouse Stories shows how such interiors now extend into entire landscapes of production.[6]
The concept from Guinard that I wish to expand on and diffract is that of overflowing life: life that cannot be completely contained or repressed by technological control. Guinard locates a resistance to capsular existence in the "slippage from laboratory to overflowing life", in plants that refuse to thrive and thereby defer the efficiency of the space programmes as a whole. She calls for revealing, "in the interstices of scientific devices", a relationship to care and to everything that cannot be mastered.[7] Rather than a site of total control, the greenhouse can therefore be approached as a leaking artificial ecosystem. I propose to follow these leaks across three registers: technical, fictional and theoretical.
1. Technical overflows
In Automated Landscapes, Marina Otero Verzier and the Het Nieuwe Instituut team document contemporary work environments at the forefront of automation, from dairy farms and greenhouses to data centres. The case studies evidence the real ecological consequences of building and powering giant artificial greenhouses and the data infrastructures they need.[1] As a counterpoint to this seminal critique, in her lecture On Heat, Desire, and the Thermopolitics of Data at the PARSE conference Some Like It Hot, Otero Verzier analysed several real-life examples where organic life disturbs algorithmic governance systems.[8]
This first section of my research collects such documented incidents in greenhouses and other "capsules", where infestation, contamination, unexpected growth or the improvised gestures of human carers disrupt the apparatus. Guinard for example records one in the MELiSSA life-support system, where a technician confides, half-guiltily, that contamination is what makes working with the living interesting.[9] What registers as error, noise or anomaly in the data streams is here valued as a trace of overflowing life.
2. Fictional overflows
In resonance with The Three-Body Problem and the dark forest theory of the internet,[10] this section scrutinizes the mediation of greenhouse ecosystems and biospheres through film and science fiction, to sketch an aesthetics of overflowing life, leakage and system breakdown, and identify its impact on technological imaginaries.
In his documentary Agrilogistics, Gerard Ortín Castellví takes us behind the closed doors of Precision Horticulture in mega automated industrial greenhouses in the Netherlands, where tulip bulbs, chrysanthemum stems and vine tomatoes are processed through cameras feeding the datasets and algorithms that regulate their growth. For Ortín, "the greenhouse is a cinematic device, an automated film set".[11] At the end of the film, after the machinic order has totally taken over the plant life, and the mesmerizing dance of computer vision and farmbots has reshaped our flux of consciousness, this weird ecology is suddenly subverted: the shadow of an animal (a llama or an alpaca?) furtively crosses the frame to go chew on some leaves. This sudden clumsy and woolly life form disrupts the implacable rhythm of the farmbots, and for a micro-second we wonder if a rewilding of these automated landscapes is actually on the way (the truth is far more sinister…).
I will study other key mediations where life overflows the technological apparatus, or where the apparatus is hacked by human or non-human agencies to produce a surplus of life: the documentary Spaceship Earth on Biosphere 2,[12] alongside news coverage and research on the project's spectacular failures, including Benjamin Bratton's reading of Biosphere 2, with its ant and cockroach infestations, as an accurate simulation of how utopian closed-loop microsocieties implode;[13] Douglas Trumbull's cult film Silent Running (1972), where a botanist sabotages his own mission to save the last forests of Earth, enclosed in geodesic domes adrift in space.[14]
3. Theoretical overflows
Where the dark forest names a withdrawal into silence and refusal, I turn to Benjamin Bratton's "rainforest" model of the internet as a counter-figure: dense, entangled, interdependent affective exchanges rather than concealment.[15] Read against the greenhouse, the rainforest theory of the internet suggests that gaps in dominant infrastructures need not only shelter retreat: they can also host noisy, overflowing, more-than-human forms of exchange and dwelling, faint signals and unidentified affects.
Post-digital ecologies demand a new vocabulary, and a compositionist ethics beyond "artificial" and "natural" divides.[16] This theoretical section explores new concepts in ecolinguistics[17] that attempt to describe our relation to artificially created and sustained biological life, and to A-life.[18] The language of control names overflows as failures, pests, contaminations or noise. Which new words could describe forms of life that are neither wild nor engineered, but have leaked through both?
Questions for the workshop
- Can overflowing life be designed for, or does any design of the gap close it again?
- Is the overflow an aesthetic category (the furtive, the nocturnal, the infested), or does it also have a biopolitics (biopolitics begins as an enclosure, wrote Sloterdijk)?
- How should a dark forest be read from inside the greenhouse: greenhouse as hiding place, dwelling or habitat?
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Bedir, Merve, Lieke Groen, Marten Kuijpers, Víctor Muñoz Sanz, and Marina Otero Verzier, eds. Automated Landscapes. Rotterdam: Het Nieuwe Instituut, 2023.
- ↑ Parikka, Jussi, and Abelardo Gil-Fournier. Living Surfaces: Images, Plants, and Environments of Media. MIT Press, 2024.
- ↑ Turnbull, Jonathon, Adam Searle, Oscar Hartman Davies, Jessica Dodsworth, et al., eds. Digital Ecologies: Mediating More-than-Human Worlds. Manchester University Press, 2024.
- ↑ Guinard, Ségolène. "Capsular Existence." Multitudes 85 (2021): 139–148. https://doi.org/10.3917/mult.085.0139
- ↑ Sloterdijk, Peter. In the World Interior of Capital: For a Philosophical Theory of Globalization. Translated by Wieland Hoban. Polity, 2013.
- ↑ Studio D.O.T.S. Greenhouse Stories. Studio D.O.T.S., 2024.
- ↑ Guinard, "Capsular Existence," p. VI (English translation).
- ↑ Otero Verzier, Marina. "On Heat, Desire, and the Thermopolitics of Data." Plenary lecture, Some Like It Hot, 6th biennial PARSE conference, Röhsska Museum of Design and Craft, University of Gothenburg, 13 November 2025.
- ↑ Guinard, "Capsular Existence," p. VIII (English translation).
- ↑ Liu, Cixin. The Dark Forest. Translated by Joel Martinsen. Tor Books, 2015 [2008]; Konior, Bogna. The Dark Forest Theory of the Internet. Polity, 2026.
- ↑ Ortín Castellví, Gerard, dir. Agrilogistics. UK/Spain, 2022. 21 min. Berlinale Shorts 2022.
- ↑ Wolf, Matt, dir. Spaceship Earth. Neon, 2020.
- ↑ Bratton, Benjamin H. "For a General Theory of Simulations." Lecture, University of Southern California / Antikythera, Los Angeles, 11 January 2024. https://antikythera.org/general-theory-of-simulations
- ↑ Trumbull, Douglas, dir. Silent Running. Written by Deric Washburn, Michael Cimino, and Steven Bochco. Universal Pictures, 1972.
- ↑ Bratton, Benjamin H. "Alternative Models of AI (at Urban Scale)." Strelka Talks, Strelka Institute for Media, Architecture and Design, Moscow, n.d. Video lecture.
- ↑ Latour, Bruno. "An Attempt at a 'Compositionist Manifesto'." New Literary History 41, no. 3 (2010): 471–490.
- ↑ Stibbe, Arran. Ecolinguistics: Language, Ecology and the Stories We Live By. 2nd ed. Routledge, 2021.
- ↑ Helmreich, Stefan. Silicon Second Nature: Culturing Artificial Life in a Digital World. University of California Press, 1998.